On this page7
- Start-Up Visa Mandamus Ruling: Key Takeaways
- What happened in the Start-Up Visa case?
- Why did the court grant mandamus?
- Does this ruling help other Start-Up Visa applicants?
- What can applicants do while waiting?
- Is the Start-Up Visa Program open to new applications?
- Need help understanding your application?
Start-Up Visa Mandamus Ruling: Key Takeaways

By Sana Mirfattah | Bright Tomorrows Immigration Services
In November 2026, Canada’s Federal Court ordered Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) to decide a delayed Start-Up Visa permanent residence application within 90 days. Read the Federal Court judgment in Naghavi v. Canada.
The applicant had applied in March 2021. According to case reports, IRCC’s notes showed the application was ready for finalization in June 2024, but no final decision followed. The court granted a remedy called mandamus, which can require a public authority to perform a legal duty.
The order applies to that applicant’s case. It requires a decision, not an approval. Other applicants must be assessed on their own circumstances.
| Question | What the ruling means |
|---|---|
| Which case? | Naghavi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1370 |
| What did the court order? | IRCC must make a decision on the applicant’s file within 90 days |
| Does the order guarantee permanent residence? | No. IRCC can still approve or refuse the application |
| Does the same deadline apply to everyone? | No. The order concerns this particular application |
| Can other applicants seek mandamus? | They can discuss their circumstances with a lawyer, but success is not automatic |
What happened in the Start-Up Visa case?
The applicant submitted a permanent residence application under the Start-Up Visa Program in March 2021. According to Livingstone Law’s case summary, IRCC’s file notes indicated that an officer had found the applicant eligible and not inadmissible by June 2024. The file was marked ready to be finalized.
The application remained in the queue. Subsequent ministerial instructions prioritized other groups of Start-Up Visa applicants. By the time the matter reached court, the applicant had waited approximately five and a half years.
The court granted mandamus and ordered IRCC to make a decision within 90 days, according to reports of the ruling. The court did not order IRCC to approve the application.
Why did the court grant mandamus?
Based on the published case summaries, the court considered whether IRCC had adequately explained the lengthy delay. It recognized that ministerial instructions can, in some circumstances, justify delays and set processing priorities.
In this case, however, the judge found that successive instructions had contributed to an open-ended delay, while IRCC had not provided a realistic completion estimate that accounted for the effect of the later instructions. The court found the explanation insufficient on the facts before it.
This does not mean that every lengthy delay is unreasonable or that every applicant can obtain a similar order. The remedy is discretionary, and the evidence in each case matters.
Does this ruling help other Start-Up Visa applicants?
The ruling may be relevant to applicants who have waited a long time, especially those whose records indicate that substantive assessments have been completed but whose files remain undecided. A lawyer can assess whether the reasoning in Naghavi could assist a particular applicant.
There are limits. Other Federal Court decisions involving delayed Start-Up Visa applications have reached different outcomes. For example, reporting on the Naghavi decision notes that the court declined mandamus in Jin v. Canada, 2026 FC 1080. The facts and explanations for delay can differ substantially between cases.
A court order to decide an application also does not determine the outcome. IRCC must still assess the application and may approve or refuse it.
What can applicants do while waiting?
If your Start-Up Visa application remains in process, consider these steps:
- Build a timeline. Record when you applied, when IRCC requested information, and when you responded.
- Keep your correspondence. Save status inquiries, responses, acknowledgements and document requests.
- Consider requesting your GCMS notes. These may help you understand what IRCC has recorded about your file, although notes do not guarantee a particular outcome.
- Check your current status. If you are in Canada, pay attention to the expiry dates and conditions of any temporary status or work permit.
- Speak with an immigration lawyer about court options. A lawyer can review the delay, the evidence and whether a mandamus application may be appropriate.
An immigration consultant can help you understand your immigration file and organize information. Federal Court representation is a separate matter: Federal Courts Rule 119 states that an individual may generally act in person or be represented by a solicitor.
Is the Start-Up Visa Program open to new applications?
IRCC currently lists the Start-Up Visa Program as paused. Its published page states that applicants needed a valid 2025 commitment certificate and had to apply by June 30, 2026. The program is closed to other applications.
The pause on new applications is separate from the question of how IRCC processes applications already in its inventory.
Need help understanding your application?
If you are waiting for a Start-Up Visa decision, Bright Tomorrows Immigration Services can help you review your immigration file and discuss your next steps. Where a court application may be appropriate, seek advice from an immigration lawyer.
Contact Bright Tomorrows Immigration Services to discuss your situation.
This article provides general information, not legal advice. Court remedies depend on individual circumstances.




